Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Top 15 2B Prospects



Each prospect ranking list factors in players who are currently at those positions. Player moves won't be factored in until they are actually made. As these lists will be updated throughout the year, you may see some big movement from previous lists. As this is a fantasy ranking list, defensive ability does not play a large roll in the rankings, and upside is valued higher than floor. As for ETA's, these are rough estimates of when I think the player will establish themselves as part of the teams lineup. Anything four plus years out is just left as the year.

Follow the jump for the rankings!


1. Dustin Ackley - SEA - ETA: Mid 2011
Ackley came into of the 2009 as one of the best pure hitters in recent memory. After a slow start to this year, his bat began to show off towards the end of the season and finally took off in the AFL. One thing that continued from college ball for Ackley was his plate discipline, which is simply amazing. His power may never be anything more than average and he may end up in the OF, but Ackley, for now, is the top 2B prospect.

2. Brett Lawrie - TOR - ETA: Mid 2012
Put me in the very small camp of people who think Lawrie will stay at 2B. To me, he looks like a really good athlete who will never come close to a gold glove, but he has the skills, not necessarily the current output, to be average there. As for his bat, Lawrie has performed at every level the Brewers challenged him at, and his projection is still higher than that. He gets lots of Uggla comps, but I could see him closer to Ian Kinsler minus the defense and injuries.

3. Jean Segura - LAA - ETA: Mid 2013
Here's is possibly my favorite prospect in all of the minors. Segura does it all. He was on my radar about halfway through last year, long before he made a joke of the Midwest League this year. There really is nothing he can't do. He makes contact with anything apposing pitchers throws, and he hits it hard. He runs fast and runs well, and is getting better. He also will be getting a run at SS this coming year, so his value may skyrocket even more.

4. Jason Kipnis - CLE - ETA: Mid 2011
Another converted OF, Kipnis has had a much better transition defensively than Ackley to 2B. Kipnis showed a good amount of power this year, and overall, his bat at 2B will play at least above average. As tough as it is to compare someone to Dustin Pedroia, Kipnis could be that kind of player when all is said and done, at least offensively. He should make a big splash in Cleveland midseason.

5. Billy Hamilton - CIN - ETA: 2014
Hamilton is a true tweener defensively, as he has plenty of range and glove, but his arm is fringey, so 2B will likely be his home down the line as it was most of this year in Rookie ball. He doesn't drive the ball a lot but when he puts the ball in play, he uses his elite speed to take extra bases, whether it be on the hit or stealing the base on the next pitch. Hamilton is a good baserunner for such a young player, so its not hard to see him stealing 50+ bases at the ML level when all's said and done.

6. Jemile Weeks - OAK - ETA: Late 2011
Weeks' biggest problem thus far is staying on the field. If he can stay healthy, Weeks will be a strong producer for the A's. He's got decent power, above average speed, decent defense, and good plate discipline. His development truly does depend on how much he can play, but the A's could have an occasional All-Star 2B on their hands, or they might have a guy who plays 50 games a year.

7. Delino DeShields Jr - HOU - ETA: 2014
Some reports going into the draft described DeShields as a very similar player to his dad, plus some power. I had to go back and look up his dad, but that would be one real impressive player. However, of the videos I saw pre-draft, I wasn't his biggest fan and had him as just the 28th best prospect heading into the draft. I think the 'Stros will tell us a lot of what they think about him with whether they send him to rookie ball or challenge him with full season A ball.

8. Scooter Gennett - MIL - ETA: Late 2013
Gennett looks like an absolute steal from the 16th round of last year's draft. The Brewers challenged him with a full season assignment and he responded by letting them know they had found their 2B of the future, enough so that they were willing to move Lawrie this offseason. Gennett, like most of the guys before him, does everything well, and the biggest challenge going forward will be to work on his plate discipline.

9. Reese Havens - NYM - ETA: Late 2012
Havens moved to 2B prior to the season and was having an absolute breakout year before getting hurt. He doesn't bring much speed to the table, but Havens, on bat alone, could be top 3 when healthy. If he can stay on the field in the next few years, the Mets will finally have the 2B that they have been missing for a while.

10. Johnny Giavotella - KC - ETA: Late 2011
 Giavotella isn't the type of player to jump off the page at you. He does, however, play the game well. His plate discipline is absolutely amazing, and he makes solid contact when he swings. His counting stats will probably sit around 10 HR's and 10 SB's a year, but he's a player who could carve out a very long career as a solid regular.

11. L.J. Hoes - BAL - ETA: Early 2013
 Hoes is a good athlete who needs to work on some of the subtleties of his game before he'll really take off. His plate discipline improved tremendously last year, but his base running did not. If he can learn to drive the ball more than he does right now, he'll take off. If not, he's likely headed to a utility roll.

12. Charlie Culberson - SF - ETA: Mid 2012
Culberson’s breakout season and AFL showed just why the Giants spent a 1st round pick on him back in 2007. He might want to watch out though, as the last 4 or 5 guys to be the top Giants 2B prospect have hit the dumps the next year. He'll have to continue the success next season, and he still has work to do, but I think he'll be a solid player going forward.



13. Adrian Cardenas - OAK - ETA: Early 2011
 Cardenas is a confusing prospect. In two partial seasons at AA, he's ripped the ball. In two extended stays at AAA, Cardenas has struggled to find consistency. He's got little power and bad base running playing against him, but he does see the ball well at the plate. If he can translate his AA results to the majors, he could be a deep league 2B if you have enough elsewhere in counting stats.

14. Daniel Descalso - STL - ETA: Early 2011
Descalso has been a good hitter his entire career. However, his power is almost non-existant. He does use decent speed to work in a fair share of doubles, so he’ll be an upgrade for Skip Schumaker, but his offensive ceiling is that of an empty batting average and a handful of SB’s a year.

15. Cord Phelps - CLE - ETA: Early 2011 
Phelps will get a chance to compete with Luis Valbuena this spring for the starting 2B job in Cleveland. Like the two guys ahead of him though, he doesn't bring a huge offensive game to the table. He did have a mini breakout at AAA this year, so his power may be blooming late, so keep an eye on him early next year.

HM: Oscar Tejeda - BOS - ETA: Late 2013, D.J. LeMahieu - CHC - ETA: Mid 2012, Corban Joseph - NYY - ETA: Late 2012

Deep Sleepers: Yowill Espinal - KC - ETA: 2015, Ryan Brett - TB - ETA: 2015, Russell Wilson - COL - ETA: 2014

No comments:

Post a Comment